ElevenLabs vs Fish Audio
ElevenLabs and Fish Audio both generate speech from text, but ElevenLabs sells a broad hosted voice suite priced per character, whereas Fish Audio sells credit based plans and ships open model weights you can run yourself. PyAI publishes this page and is left out of the capability table.
ElevenLabs
4.5 G2, 1,260 reviews
Hosted voice suite priced per character.
From $0.04 per 1,000 characters, up to $0.08
Fish Audio
4.5 G2, 119 reviews
Credit based plans with open model weights.
Free to $749/mo plans, credit based
PyAI
No G2 profile yet
Voice infrastructure with speech priced per minute.
$0.04/min Speak, $0.02/min Cast
Key takeaways
ElevenLabs vs Fish Audio in five lines
Ratings
Both score 4.5 on G2, while ElevenLabs carries 1,260 reviews against 119 for Fish Audio, so ElevenLabs has the far larger base behind the same average.
Shape
ElevenLabs is a hosted suite with dubbing, agents and speech to text, whereas Fish Audio is a leaner text to speech engine with open weights and a large community voice library.
Pricing
ElevenLabs charges $0.04 to $0.08 per 1,000 characters on plans from $0 to $990 a month, while Fish Audio sells credit based plans from $0 to $749 a month.
Openness
Fish Audio publishes open model weights you can run yourself, whereas ElevenLabs is hosted only, which matters for teams that want local control.
The gap
Both make studio audio, not 8 kHz phone audio. For real-time calls, a telephony voice such as PyAI fits better.
Which one fits
Pick your situation, get the honest answer
Every outcome below is also written out in plain text underneath, so nothing here is hidden behind the picker. Pick one option from each row, and the answer reads the first outcome that matches all three. Three outcomes point to ElevenLabs, two to Fish Audio, and the rest to a mix of tools.
What you are making
Budget
Volume
Best fit
Pick an option on the left
The answer updates as each option is chosen.
See which option fits each scenario
- Neither for calls, use PyAI. ElevenLabs and Fish Audio make studio quality audio, whereas PyAI is voice infrastructure tuned for 8 kHz phone lines. Speak runs at $0.04 a minute and Cast at $0.02 a minute, with barge-in built in.
- Fish Audio. Fish Audio ships open model weights on GitHub under a research license, so you can run the model yourself. ElevenLabs is hosted only and states no self run option.
- ElevenLabs. Only ElevenLabs lists dubbing, a Scribe speech to text model and a Conversational AI product, so a team needing more than voices stays in one account.
- ElevenLabs. For heavy voiceover work its Pro plan at $99 a month includes about 1.24 million characters, and reviewers rate its emotional range and language coverage first.
- Fish Audio, on entry price. Fish Audio's Plus plan is $11 a month with 250,000 credits and a professional voice clone, which undercuts the equivalent ElevenLabs tier for occasional work.
- Fish Audio, with a test. Open weights suit teams that want local control, though community voice quality varies, so sample the voices you need before committing to a plan.
- Either, test both. ElevenLabs leads on polish while Fish Audio leads on price and openness. Run the same script through both and judge the voices on your own ears.
- Fish Audio. On a tight budget its credit plans and free tier stretch further for light use than the ElevenLabs equivalents.
- ElevenLabs, for range. For a broad voice library, many languages and emotional control, ElevenLabs is the safer default.
Pricing
What each one costs, and what moves the number
ElevenLabs, Fish Audio and PyAI each publish a rate card. ElevenLabs bills per character, Fish Audio bills in credits, whereas PyAI bills per minute.
ElevenLabs
ElevenLabs API pricing page, October 2026.
Per 1,000 characters
Plans from Free to Business at $990 a month, Pro $99 with about 1.24 million characters. Conversational AI $0.08 a minute.
Free tier, 10,000 characters, no credit card.
Fish Audio
Fish Audio plan page, October 2026.
About 600 credits a minute
Plus $11 a month with 250,000 credits, Pro $75 with 2 million, Max $749 with 25 million. A per character rate is not published.
Free tier, 8,000 credits, personal use.
PyAI
PyAI pricing page, October 2026.
Cast long form $0.02/min
Priced per minute, not per character, with no monthly fee. OpenAI-compatible endpoints, free voice cloning, 8 kHz G.711 for phone lines. PyAI does not sell open weights to self host.
$50 free credit, no credit card.
Feature matrix
What each platform states it does
Each row records what the vendor publishes on its own pricing and product pages, read in October 2026. A blank means not stated, never assumed absent. PyAI is left out because its voice is one part of a telephony grade stack.
| Capability | ElevenLabs | Fish Audio |
|---|---|---|
| Text to speech API | ✓ | ✓ |
| Voice cloning | ✓ | ✓ |
| Multilingual voices | ✓ | ✓ |
| Emotion and audio tags | ✓ | ✓ |
| Open model weights to self run | Not stated | ✓ |
| Large community voice library | Not stated | ✓ |
| Realtime voice agents | ✓ | Not stated |
| Dubbing | ✓ | Not stated |
| Speech to text in the same account | ✓ | Not stated |
| Free tier to start | ✓ | ✓ |
| Annual billing option | ✓ | ✓ |
| ElevenLabs pricing ↗ | Fish Audio pricing ↗ |
Deep dive
Where the two actually differ
Scope, the weight of review evidence and what buyers weigh decide between ElevenLabs and Fish Audio.
Scope of the product
ElevenLabs
A hosted suite: voices, dubbing, Scribe speech to text and a Conversational AI product.
Fish Audio
A text to speech engine with open weights, a community voice library and inline emotion tags.
PyAI
Not in the table. A telephony voice in a full stack. See PyAI vs ElevenLabs.
Evidence base
ElevenLabs
4.5 out of 5 across 1,260 reviews on G2, plus 4.7 from 25 on Capterra.
Fish Audio
4.5 out of 5 across 119 reviews on G2, a smaller but real sample.
PyAI
No third party reviews yet. Speak and Cast are tuned for real-time phone audio.
What buyers weigh
ElevenLabs
Emotional range and languages, against cost once characters run out.
Fish Audio
Open weights and entry price, against mixed consistency across community voices.
PyAI
No reviews yet. Per minute billing, 8 kHz phone audio, no self hosting.
What reviewers say
Ratings and reviewer sentiment
ElevenLabs and Fish Audio scores and tag themes were read by hand from G2 in October 2026. Both sit at 4.5, though ElevenLabs draws 1,260 reviews against 119 for Fish Audio, so its sentiment is better evidenced. Cost and credits running out come up on the ElevenLabs profile, while Fish Audio has fewer reviews and no tag breakdown yet. Judge the voices on your own scripts before trusting either star rating.
ElevenLabs
- G2
- 4.5 (1,260)
- Top praise
- Quality
- Top complaint
- Expensive
Read the profile G2
ElevenLabs pricing ↗Fish Audio
- G2
- 4.5 (119)
- Tag breakdown
- None yet
- Model
- Open weights
See the Fish Audio listing on G2
Fish Audio pricing ↗Decision table
If this is your situation, pick this
Read across the row.
| If this is you | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Widest voice and language range | ElevenLabs | Large library, rated on quality |
| Running the model on your own servers | Fish Audio | Fish Speech weights on GitHub |
| Dubbing or speech to text too | ElevenLabs | Dubbing and Scribe in one account |
| Lowest entry price | Fish Audio | Plus at $11 a month with cloning |
| Building realtime voice agents | ElevenLabs | Conversational AI at $0.08/min |
| Choosing from community made voices | Fish Audio | Millions of community voices |
| Most review evidence | ElevenLabs | 1,260 G2 reviews against 119 |
| A voice for live phone calls | PyAI | 8 kHz audio at $0.04 a minute |
Both fall short
What neither one does
Neither ElevenLabs nor Fish Audio is built for 8 kHz phone audio or the turn taking a live call needs. Both make studio quality files, so call-center and receptionist teams add a telephony voice for real-time lines.
Neither
Real-time telephony voice
Capability rows record published claims, not test results.
Verdict
So which one should you buy?
ElevenLabs is the broad hosted voice suite, while Fish Audio is the leaner engine with open weights and lower entry pricing. Three outcomes below, including the one built for phone calls.
Go ElevenLabs
ElevenLabs lists dubbing, Scribe speech to text, Conversational AI and per character pricing from $0.04 to $0.08.
ElevenLabs pricing ↗Go Fish Audio
Fish Audio lists open model weights, a community voice library and credit plans from $0 to $749 a month.
Fish Audio pricing ↗Go PyAI
The voice has to answer live calls. PyAI runs Speak at $0.04 a minute on 8 kHz phone audio.
Get a sandbox key →FAQ
ElevenLabs vs Fish Audio, common questions
Is ElevenLabs or Fish Audio better?
Neither wins outright. ElevenLabs fits creators who want the widest voice range, languages and a hosted suite with dubbing and speech to text, whereas Fish Audio fits teams that want open model weights and lower entry pricing. For live phone calls, neither is built for 8 kHz audio.
Is Fish Audio cheaper than ElevenLabs?
At the entry tier, yes. Fish Audio Plus is $11 a month with 250,000 credits and a professional voice clone, while the equivalent ElevenLabs tier runs $22 with 275,000 characters. At high volume the two converge, so convert credits and characters to your real minutes before deciding.
Is Fish Audio open source?
Partly. Fish Audio publishes Fish Speech model weights on GitHub under a research license, so you can run the model yourself, whereas ElevenLabs is hosted only with no self run option. Commercial use of Fish Audio still needs a paid plan, and community voice quality varies.
Which has better voice quality?
Reviewers rate ElevenLabs highest for emotional range and multilingual quality, with 1,260 G2 reviews behind a 4.5 score. Fish Audio also scores 4.5 but from 119 reviews, and its community voices are mixed. Quality is subjective, so run the same script through both and judge on your own ears.
Can I use ElevenLabs or Fish Audio for phone calls?
Both can stream audio, but neither is tuned for 8 kHz narrowband phone lines or the turn taking a live call needs. ElevenLabs and Fish Audio make studio quality files for video, podcasts and apps. PyAI is voice infrastructure built for calls, running Speak at $0.04 a minute on telephony audio.
How does per character pricing compare to per minute?
ElevenLabs bills per 1,000 characters at $0.04 to $0.08, Fish Audio bills in credits at about 600 a minute, while PyAI bills per minute at $0.04 for Speak. To compare fairly, convert each model to the minutes you expect, since character and credit rates hide the real call cost.